Skip to Main Content
McCarty's logo topMcCarty's logo scroll
  • (970)-454-2106
  • mccartys39ecc@gmail.com
  • 37661 Co Rd 39 , Eaton
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Private Events, Parties and Groups
  • Jobs
  • Order Online
  • Reserve
  • Contact Us
  • Online Gift Card Sales
    Online Gift Card Purchase Online Gift Card Lookup
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
McCarty's logo topMcCarty's logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • About Us
  • Menu
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Private Events, Parties and Groups
  • Jobs
  • Order Online
  • Reserve
  • Contact Us
  • Online Gift Card Sales
  • Online Gift Card Purchase
  • Online Gift Card Lookup

Our Menu

MenuDaily Specials

*The following items are offered raw or cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Appetizers

Chicken Wings photo

Chicken Wings

$13.95/+
Bone-in wings tossed in Buffalo or BBQ or Teriyaki sauce served with celery and carrots and choice of ranch or blue cheese

Fried Pickles

$7.95
Crispy fried pickle spears served with a side of chipotle ranch for dipping
Cheese Curds photo

Cheese Curds

$9.95
Wisconsin Style Beer Battered Cheese Curds served with chipotle ranch

Pretzel Bites

$8.95
Soft warm pretzel pieces served with homemade queso
Jumbo Nachos photo

Jumbo Nachos

$10.95
Tortilla chips topped with warm and creamy queso, refried beans, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and candied jalapenos served with salsa and sour cream | Add Beef/Chicken/Guac $3

Chips & Salsa

$4.99
Warm tortilla chips served with our homemade salsa | Add Guacamole $3 | Add Queso $2

Irish Egg Rolls

$9.45
Shredded corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and thousand island sauce
Honey Bacon Brussel Sprouts photo

Honey Bacon Brussel Sprouts

$10.95
Crispy brussel sprouts with honey butter, smoked bacon, shaved parmesan & Balsamic glaze
Steak Strips photo

Steak Strips

$12.95
Seared flank steak strips and crispy onions, served with au jus or béarnaise

Quesadilla

$8.95
Beef or Chicken Quesadilla

The "Prime" Potato

$10.45
Two half baked potatoes stuffed with thinly sliced prime rib, topped with white gravy, cheddar jack cheese & chives

Blistered Shishito Peppers

$10.95
Blistered Shishito Peppers with our house seasoning served with a side of chipotle ranch.

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.95
Crispy & melty mozzarella served with homemade marinara sauce

Fried Portabella Mushrooms

$10.95
Fresh and meaty! Served with creamy horseradish

Fried Potato Stack

$10.95
Seasoned potato slices, loaded with cheese, smoked bacon, chopped onion and tomato. Served with a side of sour cream.

Burgers

Fire grilled 1⁄3 lb beef burger with a choice of a side

Deluxe Burger*

$10.95
Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles

Cheeseburger Deluxe*

$12.95
Topped with 2 slices of melted cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles
McCarty’s Burger* photo

McCarty’s Burger*

$16.95
Topped with shaved prime rib, American cheese, and au jus
Guacamole Bacon Burger* photo

Guacamole Bacon Burger*

$15.95
Topped with bacon, guacamole, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, & pickles
Cowboy Burger* photo

Cowboy Burger*

$15.95
Topped with bacon, crispy onions, cheddar jack cheese, BBQ sauce, lettuce, and tomato

Black and Blue Burger*

$14.95
Blackened burger patty topped with bacon, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles

Green Chili Burger*

$13.95
Smothered with our homemade pork green chili, melted cheddar jack cheese, and lettuce

Mushroom Swiss Burger

$14.95
Topped with sautéed mushrooms, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles

Salads & Soup

Dressings: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Chipotle Ranch, Italian, French, Honey Mustard, Poppyseed, Caesar, 1000 Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Oil & Vinegar

Unlimited Soup & Salad Bar

$15.95
Our delicious homemade soup & salad bar featuring an extensive of 38+ items
McCarty’s Salad photo

McCarty’s Salad

$10.95
Mixed greens topped with egg, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, cheddar jack cheese, and croutons. Add chicken, salmon, shrimp, or steak

Homemade Soup of the Day

$3.00/+
cup $3 | bowl $5

Homemade Pork Green Chili

$3.00/+
cup $3 | bowl $5

Side House/Caesar Salad

$4.00
Santa Fe Salad photo

Santa Fe Salad

$13.95
Seasoned ground beef, grilled, or crispy chicken, black bean corn salsa, cheddar jack cheese, served in a fried tortilla shell with salsa & creamy cilantro dressing
Traditional Caesar Salad photo

Traditional Caesar Salad

$10.95
Fresh Romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan, croutons, and homemade caesar dressing - Add Chicken , Steak, Salmon, or Shrimp

BBQ Chicken Cobb Salad

$14.95
Grilled BBQ chicken breast with sweet corn, black beans, hard boiled egg, cheddar jack shreds, bacon, tomato and fresh greens. Served with chipotle ranch dressing.

Fairway Favorites

All Fairway Favorites are served with a choice of a side

Rocky Mountain Dip photo

Rocky Mountain Dip

$15.95
Slow roasted thinly sliced prime rib topped with melted pepper jack cheese and spicy garlic mayo served on a hoagie roll with a side of au jus
All American Dip photo

All American Dip

$14.95
Slow roasted thinly sliced prime rib topped with melted American cheese served on a hoagie roll with au jus
Reuben photo

Reuben

$15.95
Corned beef topped with sauerkraut, swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing served on a dark marbled rye

Beer Battered Alaskan Cod

$14.95
Beer battered fish fillets served with lemon, rainbow slaw, tartar sauce, and malt vinegar
The Philly photo

The Philly

$15.95
Shaved prime rib or chicken breast topped with melted pepper jack cheese, sauteed peppers, onions, and mushrooms served on a hoagie roll

Chicken Tenders

$12.95
Crispy chicken tenders fried golden brown | Available BBQ/Buffalo or Teriyaki Style

Southwest Chicken Wrap

$14.95
Grilled or crispy chicken, cheddar jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, guacamole, and southwest ranch dressing
Smothered Burrito photo

Smothered Burrito

$13.95
Seasoned ground beef or chicken and refried beans wrapped in a flour tortilla topped and smothered with our homemade pork green chili, lettuce, and shredded cheddar jack cheese | Add Guacamole $3 | Add Queso $2

French Dip

$14.95
Thinly sliced prime rib, melted swiss cheese served on a hoagie roll with au jus
Steak Sandwich photo

Steak Sandwich

$15.95
Grilled "Trees Major" Steak, served on a slice of texas toast and a side of bernaise
Club Sandwich photo

Club Sandwich

$13.95
Smoked turkey and ham, topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese, and a side of mayo, served on texas toast

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$13.95
Grilled or Crispy Chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, pepper jack, pickles

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich

$15.95
Breaded pork tenderloin, served on a challah bun with peppercorn mayo, onions and pickles.

Elote Steak Street Tacos

$15.95
3 Flour tortillas, grilled steak strips mixed with creamy Mexican street corn, cilantro, lime and cotija cheese. Served with a side of refried beans

Chicken Salad Croissant

$13.95
Butter Croissant with classic chicken salad, grilled chicken breast, red grapes, toasted almonds and celery on fresh lettuce.

The "Cali" Sandwich

$15.95
Marinated grilled chicken breast topped with melted Swiss cheese, honey mustard, smoked bacon, guacamole, lettuce and tomato. Served on a ciabatta roll.

Entrées

All Entrées are served with two of our sides | Add 2 Jumbo Golden Fried Shrimp to any Entrée $5

14oz Ribeye Steak* photo

14oz Ribeye Steak*

$29.95
Fire grilled hand cut ribeye grilled to your preference served with a side of bearnaise
Golden Fried Shrimp photo

Golden Fried Shrimp

$18.95
Jumbo shrimp battered and fried golden brown with a side of cocktail or tartar sauce

Prime Rib*

$24.95
10oz slow cooked prime rib served with a side of au jus and two of our sides
10oz McCarty's Steak* photo

10oz McCarty's Steak*

$23.95
Top Sirloin Steak grilled to your preference with a side of bearnaise

10oz Pepper Steak*

$24.95
Top Sirloin Steak marinated in our famous homemade pepper sauce recipe served with a side of bearnaise
Fettucini Alfredo photo

Fettucini Alfredo

$13.95
Fettuccini pasta with homemade creamy alfredo sauce served with freshly sliced parmesan cheese, basil and garlic bread. Add grilled chicken, sautéed shrimp, or steak
Salmon Fillet* photo

Salmon Fillet*

$17.95
Fire grilled salmon blackened or teriyaki style served on a bed of spinach with fresh lemon slices

Coconut Shrimp

$16.95
Fried shrimp coated in sweet coconut flakes served with a tangy marmalade

Steak Medallions*

$20.95
Steak medallions served with a creamy mushroom and onion sauce, served with two of our sides
Chicken Parmesan photo

Chicken Parmesan

$17.95
Fettuccine Pasta with marinara sauce, a freshly breaded chicken breast with melted mozzarella & parmesan cheese, basil and garlic bread

Surf & Turf

$23.95
Grilled jumbo shrimp and tenderloin steak skewers with grilled tomatoes & red onion, served with lemon and cocktail sauce and two sides

Jumbo Shrimp DInner

$18.95
6 grilled jumbo shrimp brushed with garlic butter. Served with garlic butter and served with two sides

NY Strip Steak

$24.95
10 oz. Angus NY strip steak served with bearnaise or au jus

Grilled Chicken Dinner

$16.95
Grilled chicken breast seasoned with herbs, garlic and olive oil

Beef Stroganoff

$19.95
Fresh egg noodles, stewed beef coasted in a mushroom and onion cream sauce. Served with garlic bread.

Shrimp Scampi

$19.95
Fettuccine pasta with a light white wine and garlic sauce, sun dried tomatoes and sauteed jumbo shrimp. Served with garlic bread.

Dessert

Homemade Bread Pudding

Chocolate Lava Cake photo

Chocolate Lava Cake

Classic Creme Brûlée photo

Classic Creme Brûlée

McCarty's Frozen Mud Pie

"Mile High" apple pie

Deep dish apple pie with cinnamon ice cream

Seasonal Cheesecake

Ask us what we are featuring!

Lunch

Try something new!

Monday

Country Fried Steak with Mashed Potatoes, Country Green Beans, Gravy.
Tuesday photo

Tuesday

Taco Tuesday -$3 Beef or Special Taco | $4.00 Margaritas

Wednesday

The Dagwood Sandwich – Ham, Roastbeef, Bacon, American & Cheddar Cheese, LTO.

Thursday

Smoked BBQ Brisket Sandwich with Coleslaw
Friday photo

Friday

Home Made Pot Roast with Mashed Potatoes and Gravy!!

Dinner

Relax and let us take care

Monday photo

Monday

Country Fried Steak with Mashed Potatoes, Country Green Beans, Gravy

Tuesday

Taco Tuesday -$3 Beef or Special Taco | $3.00 Margaritas

Wednesday

8oz Prime Rib with two sides
Thursday photo

Thursday

8oz Prime Rib with two sides & BBQ Brisket Sandwich

Friday

8oz Prime Rib with two sides & a Chef Special

Saturday & Sunday

10oz Prime Rib with two sides & a Chef Special

Chef Special

In addition to our regular specials, our chefs create an individual special during each meal period for you. Stop by or call us and find out about today’s chef special
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs